Forcing Nursing Homes to Admit Corona Patients a Tragic Mistake

  • Date : September 1st, 2020
  • Author : Team DeStefano

Sending Coronavirus infected patients to nursing homes was a tragic mistake and I have joined the call for hearings to get to the bottom of what went wrong.

The impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic have been unprecedented, and nowhere have we witnessed more tragic effects than in New York State’s nursing homes. With more than 5,000 deaths reported, a full 25 percent of COVID-related fatalities have occurred in these state-regulated facilities.

The statistics and associated reports are deeply troubling, and demand a comprehensive review of New York’s policies, decisions, and protocols that were utilized in response to the public health crisis.

The threat of an outbreak in adult care facilities was evident early, as COVID-19 spread rapidly and caused the deaths of dozens of patients at the Life Care Center of Kirkland in the state of Washington. Despite warning signs, New York’s efforts to protect residents and staff at nursing homes appear to have fallen well short. According to reports, New York’s nursing homes lacked a sufficient amount of personal protective equipment (PPE), proper protocols for infection response and containment, and adequate testing for patients and staff.

Compounding the problem, the state Department of Health’s directive of March 25, which required nursing homes to admit individuals who tested positive for COVID-19, defied all logic and placed elderly patients and facility staff directly in harm’s way. A state-issued mandate that essentially forced our most vulnerable facilities to accept COVID-infected patients seems questionable at best, and demands further explanation. While the governor unveiled on Sunday additional preventative measures for nursing homes, it is telling that the new protocols seem to reverse – or at least limit – the original order.

The state’s own reporting of nursing home incidents has also generated additional confusion. Approximately 1,700 new COVID-19 nursing home deaths were recently added to the state’s total, a result of newly-reported instances where a patient displayed symptoms of the virus but was never actually tested. This is not only alarming, but calls into question the accuracy of what’s being reported and the true scope of the outbreak.

The Attorney General’s Office and state Health Department have announced they will investigate what has transpired in the state’s nursing homes. Others have called for federal investigations into the matter. It is incumbent upon the Legislature to conduct its own inquiry into the state’s response and how future issues might be prevented.

The members of both the Assembly and Senate will participate in hearings on the impact to small businesses. It is deeply discouraging that none of our committees – not Health, Aging, nor Oversight, Analysis & Investigations – were invited to participate in these sessions. It seems appropriate that the tragedies experienced in our nursing homes would warrant a similar forum and I will help lead the effort to get to the bottom of what went wrong.

Although metrics show a decline in the COVID-19 prevalence, we are far from the end of this crisis. Our seniors represent a highly-vulnerable segment of society, and our path moving forward must be more effective and avoid the danger that has been seen in so many facilities to date.